Kung Hei Fat Choi girls!
Wishing you all good health, happiness and success!
and oh, Happy hearts day too!
******************
I borrowed my sister's fluidline to make a comparison.
Hope you find this post useful.
Wishing you all good health, happiness and success!
and oh, Happy hearts day too!
******************
I borrowed my sister's fluidline to make a comparison.
Hope you find this post useful.
PACKAGING :
Both are made of glass jars.
WEIGHT :
MAC - 3 grams
Maybelline - 2.8 grams
MAC - 3 grams
Maybelline - 2.8 grams
TEXTURE :
MAC is a bit creamier than Maybelline.
COLOR - PAY OFF :
MAC is a bit creamier than Maybelline.
COLOR - PAY OFF :
Same intense black color.
(click images to zoom)
STAYING POWER :
(On bare hands without primer)
After a few minutes upon application, I rubbed it several times - it didn't budge or smudge!
When I placed my hand under running water and rubbed it twice, both liners smudged.
Maybelline smudged more than MAC, but hey- just a little bit!
See pic below.
(On bare hands without primer)
After a few minutes upon application, I rubbed it several times - it didn't budge or smudge!
When I placed my hand under running water and rubbed it twice, both liners smudged.
Maybelline smudged more than MAC, but hey- just a little bit!
See pic below.
TIPS:
Make sure to tightly close the jar after opening to prevent gel eyeliners from drying fast.
Other gel eyeliners I've tried:
Fanny Serrano gel eyeliner - dries easily after a month. Flaky texture.
Elianto gel eyeliner - creamy consistency at first. Dries easily too, making it difficult to use.
Make sure to tightly close the jar after opening to prevent gel eyeliners from drying fast.
Other gel eyeliners I've tried:
Fanny Serrano gel eyeliner - dries easily after a month. Flaky texture.
Elianto gel eyeliner - creamy consistency at first. Dries easily too, making it difficult to use.
FINAL THOUGHTS:
Blacktrack is a nice gel eyeliner, but if you want to save a few bucks I really recommend Maybelline! Its a dupe of MAC Fluidline IMO. I've had this for more than a month the texture is still creamy.
Blacktrack is a nice gel eyeliner, but if you want to save a few bucks I really recommend Maybelline! Its a dupe of MAC Fluidline IMO. I've had this for more than a month the texture is still creamy.
Till next time,
16 comments:
thanks for the review sis!
im loving my maybelline gel liner too :) pero hg ko na is stila smudgepots ~~
hi sis. thank you for this review. uhm, pag nag dry yung gel liners mo, try mo yung tutorial ko.. :)
I love my maybelline gel liner, too! It's the one that I use in all my FOTDs.
Is the volume/net content the same?
hindi ko pa natry yung sa maybelline,badtrip oos since december :(
Thanks for the review.i have a fanny serrano gel eyeliner but after some weeks it dried up so i returned to using my liquid eyeliner.will get the maybelline.thanks ^-^
thanks for the comments girls!
@tish - i forgot to include the weight. maybelline is 2.8g while MAC is 3g.
Thanks for the comparison! I think I'd go for the Maybelline one, it's so much cheaper plus it comes with a brush :)
is it available na here?
I haven't tried Maybelline, glad to know its good especially for ladies who doesn't want to spend much :) Great post!
thanks for the review sis..very helpful
really great review and comparison of the two! thank you very much :)
Ive seen my class mates use this, very promising hehe ill try this one next when my loreal gel liner dries out =)
Thanks for this review, definitely worth knowing!
Hi sis, just read your review about Maybelline now. I have to agree, you save more with Maybelline and their gel eyeliner is so good! I love it!
hmm... I think I'm going to buy this tonight~~~ :)
My friend had her few months old MAC eyeliner dried up (she kept it in air-conditioned room) and she only use 1/5 out of the pot. Bad2...
great post gal... i also have maybelline gel liner and was planning from long to buy mac gel liner but it is expensive so was not able to buy.. thanks to ur post i am happy and satisfied with my maybelline liner.. :)
thank u...
my recent post: Review – Sigma Hollywood Glamour Retractable Kabuki Brush – Princess Grace in Pink color
Amee :)
Post a Comment